It wasn't supposed to be like this. Never can I remember so many preseason favorites look like dogs this deep into the season. Let's look at the likely preseason divsion winner, based solely on hype alone.
AFC (The superior and more steady conference by far this season)
North: Baltimore (Hype prevails)
South: Colts...duh (Hype fails, entire division is tied and Colts are 0-2 in division play)
East: Jets (Hype prevails)
West: Chargers (Hype fails)
NFC (Bizarro World)
North: Packers (Hype fails)
South: Saints (Hype fails)
East: Cowboys (Hype falls on its face)
West: 49ers (Hype dies a miserable death)
Sure it's only week 5, but there's one hard and fast rule coming into play when picking these games: Nothing makes any sense. Dre accuses me often of pulling picks out of my ass, and often times he is right, but there's also a feel for these picks that can't be explained by stats or what seems to make any sense. Sometimes the best move is to give a team the eye test, and go with your gut. It failed me the last few weeks, but thankfully it saved me several times this week.
- Jaguars 36, Bills 26 - Jason loser, Dre winner. Anyone else expect this game to feature two of the best quarterbacking displays of the week? If you said yes, you're a liar. The Jaguars ground and air attack put up more points than the Bills could counter and the Jags now sit at 3-2 in the quagmire that is the AFC South.
- Colts 19, Chiefs 9 - Both losers. I paid very close attention to this one. Even though the Chiefs failed to cover, they played a very solid game for 50 minutes, especially on defense and with regards to sticking to their impressive ground attack. At the critical moments, however, the Chiefs main deficiency became painfully obvious: Matt Cassel sucks hard. Three point Colt leads felt immense, and when the Colts finally eked out a late touchdown, it was sad watching the Chiefs still running the ball with time running down, because that is all they can do well on offense. The Chiefs showed tremendous heart, and it really looks like they are the class of the division, but in the end their poor quarterback play will doom them.
- Bucs 24, Bengals 21 - Both winners. There's a train leaving the station and you want to be on it. Of course it's the Josh Freeman train. How impressive that a second year quarterback on the road showed more poise and patience than an established (and clearly declining) veteran. Tampa stayed within themselves, took advantage of many Carson Palmer mistakes, and Freeman made a throw reminiscent of the Matt Ryan pass that beat the Bears in Ryan's rookie campaign. Talk about a clutch toss and catch to set up the game winning FG. On the other side of the field, the Bengals are a mess. Every week now, Palmer looks more and more done. I don't think he's ever fully recovered from his leg injury of several years ago in the playoffs against Pittsburgh, or he's hiding another malady.
- Redskins 16, Packers 13 - Jason loser, Dre winner. Bizarro League Alert. The Packers were the team of destiny. The Redskins were on rebuilding plan number 437. Again the Packers jumped out to an early lead. Again the Packers stopped scoring and started making mistakes. Again the injury bugaboo haunted the Pack, right up to their final offensive play that sent Aaron Rodgers to Concussion City. The Redskins hung around, did just enough to force overtime, and then capitalized on all the Packer mistakes and delivered the knockout blow: an overtime FG that gave the Skins their only lead of the game.
- Lions 44, Rams 6 - Both losers. This game reminded me of that scene from "A Christmas Story" where Ralphie finally just beats the living shit out of the kid that's been tormenting him all through school. In a brilliant twist of irony, the beatdown that the Lions administered means that they've now scored more points than they've allowed, and that along with $2 gets them a ride on the bus (not www.thebus36.com).
- Bears 23, Panthers 6 - Jason winner. Dre loser. Dre labelled me "The Bear Whisperer" this week in our pick discussion. Once he heard me pick the Bears, for no apparent reason, he knew he was doomed. I'm not a Bear fan, but I lived in Chicago most of my life, and maybe familiarity breeds contempt at times, but it also means I can look at my hometown team objectively. Todd Collins was destined to be a non-factor in the game, and whatever running game and defense the Bears had, they were going to use it come hell or high water during Jay Cutlers vacation to Concussion City. This game truly deserves a Bizarro League Alert. Bear QB's threw for 51 yards and 4 picks, and the Bears won by 17 and sit alone in first place. Go figure.
- Giants 34, Texans 10 - Jason winner, Dre loser. In the Giants 2007 Super Bowl season, they were the Road Warriors. They also faced a lot of media scrutiny after a lackluster start to the season and Tom Coughlin found himself on the hot seat. Sound familiar? After their impressive win last week against the Bears, I expected a springboard effect for the Giants, who look suddenly relevant again and could be dangerous in the weaker than weak NFC.
- Ravens 31, Broncos 17 - Both losers. Not even Air Orton could derail the Ravens, who look to have found some balance on offense, and are beginning to assert the dominance I expected from them all along. Championship caliber teams usually get better as the season wears on, and Baltimore could be in for a special season if they keep getting better.
- Falcons 20, Browns 10 - Jason winner. Dre loser. It sounded like Dre accused me of a little homerism in my picking this week. If anything, I'm usually a little hesitant to drink the Falcon Kool-Aid when I'm making my picks. This week felt like Atlanta was ready to assert themselves, which they did....on defense.....again. This still seems to be a very underrated defensive unit, only giving up 14 points a game. Cleveland seems to have developed a bad case of Picksixitis as it seems whoever starts at QB for the Brownies will throw an embarrassing pick-6 every week. This weeks winner: Kroy Biermann, whose highlight reel interception and return sealed the win for the Falcons, and for me.
- Cardinals 30, Saints 20 - Jason loser, Dre winner. Bizarro League Alert. This one was all Dre. I know his pick of the Cards was more an anti-Saints pick than a pro-Cards pick, but damn the Saints are a mess. Last year was truly a magical season for them, which in hindsight can be said for most Super Bowl teams. Defensive scores at will, two minute offense scores almost every game, playing Brett Favre in a NFC championship game. Not once all season have the Saints looked very good, and even in their wins have looked shaky at best (and look at who the Saints beat: Minnesota, San Francisco, and Carolina with their 1-13 combined record). Arizona, much like Washington, did just enough to hang around, and then took a page out of the Saints 2009 playbook by scoring two defensive touchdowns late to take and then pad the lead.
- Titans 34, Cowboys 27 - Both losers. I literally laughed when I heard this was a seven point spread for the Cowboys. My initial reaction was to take Tennessee, but then I let stats creep into my brain, most notably how well the Cowboys perform coming off bye weeks, as well as their impressive win at Houston two weeks ago. So of course Dre and I spit in the face of God, and He smote us.
- Raiders 35, Chargers 27 - Jason winner, Dre loser. Yeah, OK, THIS one I pulled out of my ass. Sure the Chargers have been playing Bizarro League football and this is a divisional matchup, but damn. San Diego's Not-So-Special Teams were on display again, having 2 punts blocked in the first five minutes of the game! Those blocks directly gave Oakland nine points. We made fun of the Chargers Not-So-Special Teams in our pick discussion, but this is getting ridiculous now.
- Eagles 27, Niners 24 - Jason winner, Dre loser. Bizarro League Alert. Oh, the primetime games. The Niners are trying to stave off an 0-5 start against an Eagles team reeling from a loss to McNabb and losing Micheal Vick all in the same game. This game SCREAMED Niners all the way. But we forget that this is the Bizarro Football League, and the year of the demise of preseason favorites. Post-hype, the Eagles put what should amount to the final nail in the coffin of Coach Psycho and the Alex Smith Experiment.
- Jets 29, Vikings 22 - Both winners. Is it Christmastime already? Brett Favre delivered an ATS win with a patented late game pick 6. In a soaking rain, the Vikings did their best for 3 quarters to look doner than done, then pulled off a late game rally and looked like they might just pull it out. Maybe in another year, but not in Bizarro Year. The Vikings now sit with as many wins as the Lions, with their only win coming against the Lions. But things get better for the Vikings right? Nope, they get to host their Bizarro League rivals next week at home against Dallas. My best guess for the result of that game: tie.
Another rough week down. What will the BFL hold for us next week? Stay tuned....
Jason 7-7
Dre 5-9